Microwave Equipment bechmarking

[lamhd_bk]

Dear all,

I would you expert can let me know the advantage and disadvantage when comparate some Microwave vendor ( NEC, AVIAT, CERAGON, ERICSON, Huawei...)

Thanks you so much

[simog72]

the question it's very open i suggest to focalize on some aspect but..

the first answer it pop up reading you question is a specialsit/generalsit differences:

CERAGON, AVIAT are MW specialist (together with Dragonwave, SIAE )
HUAWEI and E******* are Generalist
NEC is a generalist but stand in the middle

so the first main differences are related to the nature of the MW providers:
Generalist: normally slower to introduce innovation , slow to reach top radio performances , but able to provide precious end-to-end and multitecnological solutions(Access,transport core) , some of them are adopting too much proprietary solutions
Specialsit: more reactive, more cost effective, flexible and customer oriented

this is a general statements (case by case u can have different characterizations)

next step can be a comparative more focused on technological aspect..but u need to zooming-in the picture indicating aspect u are intrested in (Split,FO, FI ...)

i hope this helps

[sedicla]

Please tell us wath you are loooking cost effective, technological aspect ?????

[eapeap]

benchmarking for what? are you purchasing a new equipment? you want the technical specification of each product?

[lamhd_bk]

benchmarking for what? are you purchasing a new equipment? you want the technical specification of each product?

Thank you,

thats gerneral question, so i would like to saperate in to things
1. Technical special
2. Price
3. whatever thing of problem when monitoring

Thanks

[m_afrasiabi]

Dear

For Price you should go for some Chineese equipment like Fiberhome and Huawei and some other like SAF and Intracom

For Performance NEC and E*** are the best with no one near them

In the middle you you can find SIAE which have both good price and good performance.

BR

[simog72]

m_afrasiabi
please tel us about NEC/E// better performances grade:
what kind of performance are u taking in account to say that?
sysgain, max modulation, power consumption , or what else


thx u

[lamhd_bk]

Dear

For Price you should go for some Chineese equipment like Fiberhome and Huawei and some other like SAF and Intracom

For Performance NEC and E*** are the best with no one near them

In the middle you you can find SIAE which have both good price and good performance.

BR

As i know
E// and Huawei, NEC is general supplier
SIAE, AVIAT, Dragonwave is top of Microwave vendor

I would like to get the benchmarking of them.

p/s: everything that you can compare which alway better for me

Rgs

[byja]

As i know
E// and Huawei, NEC is general supplier
SIAE, AVIAT, Dragonwave is top of Microwave vendor

I would like to get the benchmarking of them.

p/s: everything that you can compare which alway better for me

Which car is the best? A Ferrari can go much faster, compared to Land Cruiser, but Ferrari can't climb to the top of the hill.

Same with MW, you need to compare a lot of different factors, some which are relevant to you, some are not. And in the end, it's usually the price that decides.
You were given a list of vendors with good and reliable products, you can choose between them and you'll never go wrong. Go and look for the lowest price but make sure that you covered everything.

[lamhd_bk]

Which car is the best? A Ferrari can go much faster, compared to Land Cruiser, but Ferrari can't climb to the top of the hill.

Same with MW, you need to compare a lot of different factors, some which are relevant to you, some are not. And in the end, it's usually the price that decides.
You were given a list of vendors with good and reliable products, you can choose between them and you'll never go wrong. Go and look for the lowest price but make sure that you covered everything.

That is one thing when compare the product together. So I would like to do the same with Microwave Vendor