Thanks Thanks:  2
Page 2 of 2 FirstFirst 12
Showing results 11 to 20 of 20

Thread: Which is the best RNP tool?

  1. #11
    Member Reputation: 289
    Join Date
    2010-07-09
    Posts
    206


    Default Re: Which is the best RNP tool?

    for telecom, my choice is Atoll by Forsk.
    for broadcast, ATDI ICS Telecom.

  2. #12
    Member Reputation: 112
    Join Date
    2007-06-29
    Posts
    56


    Default Re: Which is the best RNP tool?

    Atoll for me
    More user friendly and more efficient.

  3. #13
    Member Reputation: 129
    Join Date
    2011-03-26
    Posts
    148


    Default Re: Which is the best RNP tool?

    the greatest tools is Atoll

  4. #14
    Member Reputation: 426 Darko's Avatar
    Join Date
    2008-11-03
    Location
    Europe
    Posts
    442


    Talking Re: Which is the best RNP tool?

    And Oscar goes to..... Atoll !!!

  5. #15
    Member Reputation: 38
    Join Date
    2010-01-06
    Posts
    88


    Talking Re: Which is the best RNP tool?

    my opinion: aircom asset is very powerful, extremely flexible but not very user friendly, atoll on the other end is just about the most user friendly..then again the more important thing is how skillful are you with a tool and not how powerful is the tool

  6. #16
    Senior Member Reputation: 591
    Join Date
    2010-05-10
    Posts
    343


    Default Re: Which is the best RNP tool?

    Quote Originally Posted by GonzaloChile View Post
    Hi guys:

    Which is the best RNP tool?
    and why?

    Regards
    Aircom's Asset would be the best tool, but it requires prior installation of Oracle. I have found Fork's Atoll to be very simple and user friendly.

  7. #17
    Member Reputation: 129
    Join Date
    2011-03-26
    Posts
    148


    Default Re: Which is the best RNP tool?

    OK, not to discuss further. Stop and change another topic

  8. #18
    Member Reputation: 127
    Join Date
    2010-11-19
    Posts
    224


    Default Re: Which is the best RNP tool?

    Quote Originally Posted by koepret View Post
    before , i have same question like you bro , but after i am think , difficult to answers
    defend of you , and which place you using that tool ( Operator or Vendor ) , beucase every tool have strength and have weakness .

    if you work in Operator may be you can choose one from many RNP Tool ,
    but if you work in Vendor , you must use vendor tool , usually they are have tool for themselves , like
    E******* = TCPU ( May be will be change to X-WIZARD from Optimi )
    NSN = Netact ( Aircom or Asset ) but some project , they use Atoll
    HUAWEI = UNET ( Atoll base )
    Alcatel Luncet = Airpro ( May be Base on Atoll also )
    Motorolla = ------
    ZTE = some project use Aircom
    Samsung = ----- and Another vendor
    and many Another software prepare by Manage service like
    Mentum Planet , Actix Radio Plan , ATDI Telecom , Cell Planner and Etc

    common RNP tool is Atoll , Aircom , TCPU and Mentum Planet . may be you can use from that common tool , base on my experience Aircom more powerful tool but little bit complex , easy tool but good is Atoll second choice , Mentum and TCPU is same grade

    so, we are lucky in this forum you can find all that tool
    Enjoy and choose your tool

    Dear koepret;

    Thanks alot for your clarification.

    In my opinion professional engineer should be capable to work with more than one tool and compare the result of these tools for same project.fficeffice" />>>
    I am interested to learn other planning tools like Atool and Asset, hope to get the time for this issue.>>
    >>
    Thanks again brothers in this forum for the good knowledge>>

    Regards
    Ahmed Al-Shawi

  9. #19
    Junior Member Reputation: 10
    Join Date
    2010-02-15
    Posts
    4


    Default Re: Which is the best RNP tool?

    A few years ago I would have answered Atoll. But Planet 5 is now winning in my view; more powerful, delivers more accurate results, and now very easy to use. By the way, Mentum, who own Planet, have also bought TCPU from E*******; I assume they are porting its goodies to Planet?

  10. #20
    Member Reputation: 214
    Join Date
    2010-02-27
    Posts
    155


    Default Re: Which is the best RNP tool?

    my opinion: as simplicity most of the engineers are using Atoll as fast to go and get fast results without taking care of accuracy, but for whom looking accuracy and user friendly tool they are comfort with Mentum planet, as complicated tool and oracle database (more secured) and more time consuming to process you can use Asset but accurate one also.

Tags for this Thread

Bookmarks

Bookmarks

Posting Rules

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •